It’s hard to believe that another awards season has come and gone. As always, the five days that encompassed the Edgar Allan Poe Awards in New York City and the Malice Domestic Convention in Bethesda, Maryland were jam-packed. It all began for us on Wednesday, April 27, when EQMM’s Robert L. Fish Award winner Russell W. Johnson and his wife Michelle stopped in at our offices on Wall Street to record a podcast of Russell’s winning story, “Chung Ling Soo’s Greatest Trick,” which you can listen to through a link on our website beginning June 1.

The EQMM Readers Awards are given each year on the same day as the MWA’s Edgar Allan Poe Awards, at a Dell Magazines cocktail party preceding the Edgars banquet. The Dell party was at a new venue this year, the beautiful, historic library of the General Society of Mechanics and Tradesmen. Our guests included three of our 2015 Readers Award winners, all of whom we congratulate: Margaret Maron (1st place for “We on the Train”), Brendan DuBois (tied for 2nd place for “The Lake Tenant”), and Lou Manfredo (3rd place for “Rizzo’s Good Cop”). William Hallstead (who tied for 2nd place for “No Cabs After Midnight”) was unable to make the trip from Florida, but the longtime EQMM contributor’s many decades of contributions to our field (starting with his penning of the 31st book in the Hardy Boys series!) were remembered in his absence.

In a surprise twist for your editors and the rest of the EQMM staff, EQMM itself received an award at this year’s cocktail party. We knew that EQMM’s book review columnist, Steve Steinbock, had accepted an award on the magazine’s behalf from the Baker Street Irregulars (the world’s oldest Sherlockian organization) at their annual banquet this past January. But as the honor was, at least in part, for the reviewing of books of Sherlockiana, we thought the award had found its proper home with Steve. When he crossed the country with it at the end of last month to present it for permanent housing at our offices we were truly touched. Our thanks go to both the BSI and Steve; the plaque will have pride of place in EQMM’s space.

This year’s Edgar Allan Poe Awards banquet marked the 70th anniversary of the presentation of the awards in Poe’s name. It was not, however, the 70th year in which the coveted busts of Poe that we’re all so familiar with were given. That small treasure, designed by Peter Williams, didn’t appear until 1948, the third year of the awards. This year’s best short story Edgar went to Stephen King, for “Obits,” from Bazaar of Bad Dreams; we want to give a big shout out to him and also to Mat Coward, whose EQMM story “On Borrowed Time” was one of five stories (out of 600 or more submitted) to receive an Edgar nomination.

No sooner were the Edgar Awards festivities over (for some in the wee hours of the morning) than it was time to get ready to board trains for Washington, D.C. to join the annual Malice Domestic Convention in Bethesda. One of the most welcoming and relaxed of all the events on the mystery calendar, Malice this year was a great way to conclude several days of reconnecting with friends in the mystery community. At the Agatha Awards banquet, EQMM’s latest Readers Award winner, Margaret Maron, took home the Agatha Award teapot for best novel for the last book in her very popular and long-running Judge Deborah Knott series, Long Upon the Land. Two other authors with strong ties to EQMM took home awards this season that I want to mention. One is the current president of the U.K.’s Detection Club, Martin Edwards. A writer who got his start in EQMM’s Department of First Stories, Martin has become not only a leading fiction writer but a noted scholar in our field. His book The Golden Age of Murder claimed both the Edgar and the Agatha in the best critical category. Taking home the Agatha Award for best first novel was EQMM’s frequent contributor Art Taylor. Art also got his start in our Department of First Stories, and his winning book, On the Road With Del and Louise, is actually a “novel in stories,” including a couple of stories that first saw publication in EQMM.

At the Agatha Awards banquet I had the privilege of sitting at a table hosted by this year’s Lifetime Achievement Award winner Katherine Hall Page. There I had the pleasure of catching up with Terrie Farley Moran, EQMM’s nominee for the Agatha Award, for her November 2015 story “A Killing at the Beausoleil.” The short-story Agatha went to Barb Goffman for her AHMM story “A Year Without Santa Claus?”—congratulations, Barb and AHMM!—but an enthusiastic hats off is also due to Terrie for a story that reflects the best in the classical tradition!

Finally, the winner this year of the Malice Domestic Convention’s Amelia Award, for contributions to the field, was Douglas Greene, the founder and owner of Crippen & Landru Publishers, the genre’s most distinguished line of single-author short-story collections. Doug has been a stalwart friend of our magazine, and many of his collections have been drawn largely from EQMM. Doug’s wife Sandi, who worked side by side with him at Crippen & Landru for many years, was with him to enjoy the celebration of Doug’s achievements, which include his definitive biography of John Dickson Carr.

Credits are given for all of the pictures in this season’s photo gallery, but a special thanks is due to one of the photographers, EQMM and AHMM’s wonderful senior assistant editor, Jackie Sherbow. —Janet Hutchings

The crowd at the Dell Magazines Pre-Edgars Party at the General Society of Mechanics and Tradesmen, NYC. (Photo courtesy of Jackie Sherbow)

Dell Magazines' Peter Kanter presents Lou Manfredo with EQMM Readers Award certificate

Dell Magazines’ Peter Kanter presents Lou Manfredo with EQMM Readers Award certificate (photo courtesy of Jackie Sherbow)

Brendan DuBois accepts his Readers Award (photo courtesy of Jackie Sherbow)

Margaret Maron accepts her Readers Award. (Photo courtesy of Jackie Sherbow)

Steve Steinbock presents EQMM with the Baker Street Irregulars' Tip of the Deerstalker Award. (Photo courtesy of Jackie Sherbow)

Steve Steinbock presents EQMM with the Baker Street Irregulars’ Tip of the Deerstalker Award. (Photo courtesy of Jackie Sherbow)

Dell Magazines staff relaxes at the Yale Club between the Dell Pre-Edgars party and the Edgars banquet. (Carol Demont, Janet Hutchings, Christine Begley, Linda Landrigan, Abigail Browning, Emily Hockaday. Photo courtesy of Jackie Sherbow)

Janet Hutchings, Brendan DuBois, Linda Landrigan at the Edgars. (Photo courtesy of Jackie Sherbow)

Janet Hutchings, Jackie Sherbow, Linda Landrigan. (Photo by Michelle Johnson)

At the Edgars: Russell Johnson, Michelle Johnson, Dorothy Cannell, Margaret Maron, Janet Hutchings, Linda Landrigan, Carol Demont, Abigail Browning, Lou Manfredo, Joanne Manfredo, Brendan DuBois. (Photo courtesy of Jackie Sherbow)

Breakfast during Malice: First row L to R: Sandi Greene, James Lincoln Warren, Margaret Warren, Steve Steinbock. Second row, L to R: Art Taylor, Laurie Pachter, Martin Edwards, Janet Hutchings, Josh Pachter, Doug Greene. (Photo courtesy of Josh Pachter)

Agatha nomination certificate. (Photo courtesy Terrie Farley Moran)

Agatha nomination certificate for “A Killing at the Beausoleil.” (Photo courtesy of Terrie Farley Moran)

Art Taylor and Terrie Farley Moran. (photo courtesy of Terrie Farley Moran)


Martin Edwards and his Agatha Award. (Photo courtesy of Terrie Farley Moran)

This entry was posted in Awards, Ellery Queen, Genre, Writers and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.


  1. Enjoyed reading the recap here! Such a fun week of festivities—and I need to make it up to the pre-Edgars cocktail party another year for sure. I miss seeing everyone there. Thanks for including me here—and great seeing you in Bethesda, Janet!

  2. Meg Mims says:

    Congrats to you all! How wonderful that EQMM also won an award!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s